When Can Suspensions Be Unreasonable?

An NHS Trust was taken to court, after the claimant seeks a temporary injunction following her suspension from duties.

In the recent case of Harrison v Barking, Havering and Redbridge University Hospitals NHS Trust, an employee successfully argued that her suspension was unreasonable. The court ordered a mandatory interim injunction allowing her to resume the majority of her normal duties at work.

What Happened?

The claimant is the Deputy Head of Legal Services for an NHS Trust and was suspended following concerns about her handling of a clinical negligence case. She had not previously received criticism of her casework. Following her suspension, she was diagnosed with stress and prescribed anti-depressant medication. She had not previously suffered from mental health issues.

The Trust advised that the claimant could return to work on restricted duties. She refused, as she claimed this was a demotion and contrary to medical advice, that returning to full duties would improve her health. She was then suspended again for refusing to obey an instruction.

The claimant sought an interim injunction permitting her to perform the majority of her normal duties autonomously whilst the Trust’s investigation was carried out.

Was This Suspension Reasonable?

In considering the application for a temporary injunction, the court needed to consider whether the claimant had an arguable case that the Trust’s actions amounted to a breach of the implied duty of trust and confidence.

The court concluded that there was a strongly arguable case on the following grounds:

  • On the facts of the case, there was arguably no reasonable and proper cause for the suspensions imposed by the Trust.
  • The criticisms of particular aspects of the claimant’s work, which purported to justify the restriction of her duties had been made after the decision to suspend her was taken.
  • The Trust had failed to challenge the claimant’s assertion that the allegation that she had been rude towards panel solicitors had not previously been raised with her during her appraisals.

What Can You Learn From This?

This case is an important reminder for employers to carefully consider whether suspension is an appropriate action in the circumstances. Suspensions should usually be a last resort and not a knee-jerk response.

In circumstances where an employer considers that suspension is a reasonable action, careful consideration should be given to ensure the decision is proportionate. There must be proper reasons given and sufficient supporting evidence to support that decision making.

For more information, please contact Sarah Martin on 07799 136 091 or Caitlin Anniss on 07909 683 938 at Narrow Quay HR